U4N - Discover 14 Rare MLB The Show 25 Bullpen Cards for Ranked Mode

[FrostFlare]

When you’re grinding through Ranked Seasons in MLB The Show 25, having a deep and versatile bullpen isn’t just a luxury—it’s a requirement. Especially as you face off against skilled opponents with lightning-fast reaction times and smart lineups, having that clutch lefty specialist or underrated setup man can mean the difference between a W and an L. In this guide, we’ll break down 14 rare bullpen cards that can quietly dominate in Ranked, often overlooked by the broader community but deadly in the right hands.

1. 1981 Rollie Fingers (Prime)
This card has elite control, with pinpoint accuracy on his sinker, slider, and splitter mix. Great for tight games in the late innings.

2. 2022 Devin Williams (All-Star)
The “Airbender” changeup is still a nightmare for hitters. His delivery also creates deception, making him tough to square up even when opponents expect off-speed.

3. Signature Series Aroldis Chapman
Yes, Chapman isn’t “rare” in terms of name recognition, but his Signature Series card is a reward-tier gem with maxed-out velocity and solid BB/9 stats that aren’t typical for him.

4. 2010 Koji Uehara (Postseason)
Not a card most players expect to see, Koji’s elite control and deceptive splitter make him ideal for clutch 8th-inning holds.

5. 2004 Francisco Cordero (Milestone)
An uncommon bullpen piece, Cordero’s card combines velocity with break. He doesn’t get much love, but in Ranked he gets results—especially against aggressive hitters.

6. 2020 James Karinchak (Breakout)
His motion and power curveball combination throw hitters off. He's ideal for surprise situations where you need a punch-out.

7. 2008 Trevor Hoffman (Signature)
Low velocity, high control, and devastating off-speed pitches. Perfect when you’re playing mind games against hitters sitting on heat.

8. 1996 John Wetteland (Postseason)
This one is a bit of a sleeper. Wetteland’s card includes a solid cutter/four-seamer combo and works especially well in a bullpen-by-committee setup.

9. 2021 Tyler Rogers (Topps Now)
A sidearm delivery in MLB The Show 25 is always tricky to time. Rogers is effective in Ranked if you use him in specific matchups.

10. 2023 Erik Swanson (Monthly Awards)
Solid all-around stats and rarely seen in Ranked, making him unpredictable for opponents used to seeing the same few relievers every match.

11. 1991 Rob Dibble (Milestone)
His heater can touch 102 MPH, and it feels even faster due to his explosive delivery. Combine with a solid slider and he’s a nightmare.

12. U4N Exclusive Program Lee Smith
This bullpen legend appears as a limited-time card during the U4N Challenges. He’s well-rounded and reliable, especially under pressure.

13. 2017 Dellin Betances (Breakout)
Tall delivery, high strikeout rate, and crazy vertical break on his curve. Perfect for throwing hitters off-balance.

14. 2002 Billy Wagner (Prime)
As a lefty with overpowering speed and movement, Wagner’s rare Prime card can anchor the back end of any bullpen with confidence.

Why These Cards Matter in Ranked
Most Ranked players flock to meta bullpen arms like Josh Hader or Emmanuel Clase, but savvy players who want a competitive edge should seek out lesser-used but high-performing cards. These rare bullpen pieces give you flexibility, matchup control, and surprise factor—three keys to winning games late.

If you're short on resources, grinding for these cards can take time. Many players turn to efficient resource management or even buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to complete collections faster. Whether you're on PlayStation or need MLB 25 stubs Xbox, staying ahead of the Ranked curve often comes down to roster depth and bullpen usage.

Services like U4N have become popular among the community for helping players get what they need to compete in Ranked without wasting time. The key is knowing which bullpen cards are worth investing in—and these 14 are among the most impactful you can find.

Whether you’re chasing World Series or just trying to improve your win rate, don’t underestimate the power of an elite bullpen. Now’s the time to rebuild your pen with a few arms your opponents won’t see coming.