Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post Reply
inventabuild
Posts: 271
Joined: 09 Nov 2014, 23:03

Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post by inventabuild »

Jonathan,

Can you give KISSlicer the ability to generate low % infill in the center of the part and high % infill at the skin interface with the infill transitioning from low % to high% and the user can define these low / high values?

I'm thinking it will save print time and filament without sacrificing strength.
User avatar
Davide Ardizzoia
Posts: 122
Joined: 07 Nov 2014, 13:05
Location: Oleggio, Italy
Contact:

Re: Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post by Davide Ardizzoia »

I believe it could be quite difficult to implement.
Preserving strengt is a very difficult argument. Nature itself has animals with hollow (but weak) bones like the birds ones, or massive (and heavy) bones like the elephant ones...
There are many other ways to speed up printing time (i.e.: stacked infill) !

Best Regards
Davide Ardizzoia
inventabuild
Posts: 271
Joined: 09 Nov 2014, 23:03

Re: Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post by inventabuild »

Actually I think you proved my point. Bird bones are stronger and stiffer pound for pound than the bones of similarly sized mammals because bird bones are denser even though they are hollow and thinner than mammal bones (https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2 ... 112103.htm). Furthermore, similar to 3d printing, bird bones do have struts ("infill") as supports for their bones...most people are printing bird bones they just don't realize it because they make them look like lizards or some other cool object :)
Bird Bone
Bird Bone
Bird Bone.jpg (10.36 KiB) Viewed 1966 times
Clearly 3D printing a solid object will be stronger than an object that has infill less than 100% assuming the layers are rotated to give equal strength in all directions, but my hypothesis is that if we are going to print with some % infill (as most people do) then it is better to have denser infill near the skin of the part rather than a less dense infill evenly distributed throughout the part.

Furthermore, assuming you are going to print 100 gms of infill for a part, I hypothesis it might help improve the cosmetics of the top layer especially on flat surfaces if lower density infill (say 10%) is used in the center of the part and denser infill (say 90%) is used closer to the skin at the top of the part instead of using 50% infill throughout the whole part.

The issue is how hard would it be to implement such variable % infill in KISSlicer to prove or disprove all this.

Wow, I never thought when I got interested in 3d printing that I would be talking about bird bones :)
User avatar
EddyMI3D
Posts: 81
Joined: 03 Oct 2015, 17:12

Re: Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post by EddyMI3D »

Makes me remember this Voronoi stuff.
Maybe this could be a task of the 3D design program to create this voronoi filling in 3d...
User avatar
Davide Ardizzoia
Posts: 122
Joined: 07 Nov 2014, 13:05
Location: Oleggio, Italy
Contact:

Re: Variable % Infill From Center To Skin

Post by Davide Ardizzoia »

Voronoi infill sounds interesting, but surely not time effective.
Slic3r has 3d hex infill that could be a bit more effective.

Best Regards
Davide Ardizzoia
Post Reply